Very nice. We usually do the Devils highway ride at least twice a year so I will consider this.
We really love the Tal-Wi-Wi lodge, check out their website. You are correct about doing the highway from south to north. From Alpine we go west, cross into New Mexico head south and do the loop, the loop is 200 miles plus and is an all day ride but definitely worth it. The Copper mine in Morenci is incredible as is the entire region. I must say this is my favorite area in around New Mexico to ride in. Last year while riding the highway north to Alpine we saw at least half a dozen creatures run across the road in front of us that looked like monkeys with long horizontal tails, don't know what they were, but it was spooky.
